After state-sponsored school segregation was ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in Brown v. Board of Education in 1954, many southern states employed a variety of legal maneuvers to avoid school integration. Public officials in Mississippi used two methods: delay and the threat of school closure.
Delay as a Form of Massive Resistance
When asked about Mississippi’s response, one state official said the state could postpone integration for another “50 or 75 years” because Mississippi legislators had “an almost endless variety of methods” available to them to kick the can of compliance down the road. Mississippians, this state official noted, could avoid integrating their classrooms by doing something like constructing one high school with two buildings. According to the official, “Negroes would go to one building of the high school, whites to another.” In other words, the state could just figure out ways to address the integration issue without really addressing it.
Threats of Public School Closure
Another strategy for non-compliance with Brown Mississippians could use would be to simply dissolve their public schools. The Supreme Court ruled on Brown in May 1954. By December 1954, the Mississippi legislature had proposed a constitutional amendment that would remove the state’s constitutional obligation to provide some form of free, public schooling to its citizens.
According to Mississippi Governor Hugh L. White, the amendment would give the state legislature direct authority to operate the public schools. And, by extension, the governor was quick to point out that:
It would authorize the Legislature by two-thirds vote of those present and voting in each house to abolish the public schools in the state, should the need arise. It would [also] authorize the Legislature to enact legislation through which the counties and school districts might abolish public schools, should the need arise.
In the event the Mississippi legislature decided to abolish the public schools, the governor pointed out that the amendment “would authorize the Legislature to appropriate funds in order to finance the education of the educable school children of the state.” This proposed constitutional amendment would give the Mississippi legislature the authority to replace the state’s public schools with a private ones. Here’s how the governor put it:
It [the amendment] is not a threat to public education. It is my view that under it the people can continue to expect the operation of public schools in the State of Mississippi, and that, if our separate public school system is destroyed by the federal courts—not by the Mississippi Legislature—our people can still continue to have their children educated in separate schools, at state expense, through a system operated under provisions of this constitutional amendment.
This strategy was the no segregation, no public schools response to Brown.
State Non-Compliance with Brown
These “let’s build a school with one building for Black students and another one for white students” and “why don’t we just abolish the public schools and replace them with private ones” methods for non-compliance with Brown weren’t the only massive resistance ploys attempted by the southern states. In an essay in History of Education Quarterly, educationalist Michael Fultz pointed out that by 1957:
8 Southern states passed states’ rights interposition resolutions, while 2 others passed manifestos of protest; 4 states abolished their constitutional requirements for public education; 6 states passed legislation denying funds to schools which desegregated; and 11 states repealed or modified compulsory attendance laws.
So, even though the tools for non-compliance were many and were varied across the southern states, the goals were the same: avoid integration at all cost. By upholding white supremacy and perpetuating injustice, many white southerners roadblocked democratic society.
Complicated Politics of School Segregation
The politics of delay and the threat of public school closures by Mississippi’s white political elite hide the complicated politics of school desegregation. White Mississippians did not agree on every massive resistance tactic. Southern School News reported that a group called Friends of Segregated Public Schools opposed granting blanket public school closure authority to the state government. Some segregationists feared that getting out of the public school business would be giving up too much in defense of segregation. Others regarded the threat of closure as a necessity to protect their children.
Historian Michael Fultz points out that segregationists used several different strategies to maintain segregated schooling: from weakened constitutional commitments to public education to disallowing the use of state monies to facilitate integration to modification of compulsory attendance requirements. The complicated politics of massive resistance were one of competing priorities, policy frameworks, and political strategies to support segregation.
Why This History Still Matters
Post-Brown school desegregation wasn’t just a conversation about education, classroom resources, or whose kids could go to which schools. It was also a conversation about democracy, justice, and the values that define American society.
Mississippi’s response to Brown exposed the conditions white leaders placed on their commitment to public education. Faced with a ruling against racial segregation, white public officials explored postponing compliance and authorizing the state to abolish public schools. Their willingness to contemplate dissentingly the system revealed how closely support for public schooling could depend on preserving white control over it.
This history matters because the democratic promise of a society become meaningful through the decisions that govern everyday life. Mississippi’s “almost an endless variety of methods” for non-compliance with Brown shows how much ingenuity could be poured into avoiding the state’s commitment to democracy. The struggle to implement Brown was also a struggle to make American society answerable to the people it had long excluded.
More to come soon.
References
“Showdown Could Be Postponed 75 Years, State Official Says.” Hattiesburg American. May 18, 1954.
Fultz, Michael. “The Displacement of Black Educators Post-Brown: An Overview and Analysis.” History of Education Quarterly 44, no. 1 (Spring 2004): 11-45.
“White says state fighting to survive in school vote.” The Clarion-Ledger. December 17, 1954.
