On November 24, 1969, Dr. Franklin Shumake, president of the Georgia Education Association, told a reporter for the Atlanta Constitution that he had detected a new “nose-against-the-wall” attitude from school leaders on integration. School officials had a constitutional obligation to dismantle segregation. Yet, carrying out that responsibility could provoke white families to abandon the public schools and place their support behind private alternatives.
One principal reported that his superintendent told him, “I’m going to integrate, but it might be the last thing I’ll do.” And another principal warned, “there is good money” supporting the private school movement that had gotten underway in his county.
These school leaders saw that desegregation would require more than their ability to make administrative restructuring decisions. Integration would test whether white communities would remain committed to public education when they could no longer preserve exclusive educational authority and control over their schools.
Most of the public school principals the Constitution’s reporters talked to agreed that the status of the new private schools springing up around the South didn’t matter: not the quality of their teachers; not their curricular resources; not the state of their facilities. The only thing that mattered was how white their student populations would be. As one school leader put it, “They [white families] just don’t want to be going down to what was a Negro school.” While the public schools integrated, many white families pulled their kids out and put them in the new private classrooms.
Infinite Delay Times Out
After the Supreme Court ruled school segregation unconstitutional in Brown v. Board of Education, many school districts across the South adopted freedom of choice desegregation plans. These plans allowed all of a district’s students to choose which school in the district they wanted to attend—regardless of whether they were assigned to that school or whether the school was traditionally zoned for white or Black students. Not surprisingly, freedom of choice plans encouraged very little integration.
When the Supreme Court ruled freedom of choice plans that did not lead to meaningful integration unconstitutional in Green v. County School Board of New Kent County on May 27, 1968, white southerners who had hoped to avoid the integration issue were faced with a new reality. The Court said that a policy that formally offered school attendance choices on paper but continued to preserve segregation in practice could not satisfy the constitutional requirements of Brown. Where more effective alternatives to integration were reasonably available, the Court pointed out, school officials had to use them.
Then, on October 29, 1969, the Court ruled in Alexander v. Holmes County Board of Education that the language of “all deliberate speed” in Brown II had expired. The Court directed the immediate termination of the dual school system. As such, many white families abandoned public schools for new private academies.
Segregation Academies and Un-Regulation
These new private schools—schools we now refer to today as segregation academies—opened up (sometimes literally) overnight. According to the Atlanta Constitution, even though quality was problem:
The State Education department, the GEA, and the organization of well-established private schools in the state all support legislation to set standards for private schools. But political opposition is stiff. Such legislation has failed in the past, and many observers give it little chance for the future.
Once the inevitability of public school desegregation took hold across the South, the southern segregationists who had pushed back against any and all integration initiatives found a new form of massive resistance: un-regulation of and support for the new private schools. In the context of desegregation, oversight of private schools raised questions about the reach of public authority. A vote to regulate these new segregation academies was often interpreted as a vote for integration.
Gubernatorial Support for White Educational Exit
Georgia Governor Lester G. Maddox provided another form of support for segregation academies: the stamp of public approval. In remarks to Valdosta Christian Schools, he described these new private schools as true expressions of Americanism.
Here’s how he put it:
It is wonderful to be with God’s people—people who love the American way of life and who believe that education should include discipline, integrity, and character building.
Maddox went on to attack federal intervention in schooling, blamed public education for social disorder, and criticized educators and officials who complied with federal demands.
He also argued that both public and private education were necessary endeavors—enabling him to support private schools while also saying he had not given up on the public ones, even while he denounced public school authorities for managing desegregation. In doing do, he gave the founders and supporters of segregation academies public legitimacy as just another form of schooling in the marketplace of education.
Why This History Still Matters
The public school leaders interviewed by the Atlanta Constitution in 1969 were watching their local white community members reorganize their commitments around new schools. Segregation academies had consequences for what children learned about race, belonging, and whose interests an educational institution should serve.
Schools matter for how societies are created, maintained, and cultivated. When adults build schools to preserve racial segregation and then celebrate their decisions as a defense of educational quality, they offer their children a certain explanation of the world. White supporters of segregation academies often pitched their schools as the definition of good schooling while framing integration as a social ill they needed to protect their families from. The very existence of these new whites-only schools communicated those messages.
In a study of parents and children at a Mississippi segregation academy, sociologist Courtney Heath Windhorn found that radicalized understandings of good schooling shaped parental choices and crafted their children’s interpretations of racial inequality. Windhorn’s study suggests that schools can teach children to understand and justify race and racial boundaries through the environments adults create for them.
The growth of segregation academies changed the school landscape across the South. In parts of the region’s Black Belt, the dismantling of the state-sponsored, legally-minded dual school system created predominately Black public schools alongside almost exclusively white private academies. When children grow up attending racially segregated schools, they miss out on the democratic possibility of building community with those who are different from them.
More to come soon…
References
Bowler, Mike. “Principals Gloomy Over Private Schools.” The Atlanta Constitution, November 24, 1969.
Maddox, Lester. (1969, September 7). Text of remarks prepared for delivery by Governor Lester Maddox to the Valdosta Christian Schools, Valdosta, GA, on Sunday, September 7, 1969, at 1:30p.m. RCB 9282: GOVERNOR – EXECUTIVE DEPT. – GOVERNOR’S SPEECH TRANSCRIPTS – 1969, August thru 1970, March – Gov. Lester Maddox: Speech Texts, Georgia Archives, Atlanta, GA.
Windhorn, Courtney Heath. “Whitewashing Our Children’s Education: Examining Segregationist School Choice in the Rural South.” Master’s thesis, Mississippi State University, 2019.
